Scone !
I am not a bot
- Joined
- Jan 16, 2015
- Messages
- 6,451
- Reaction score
- 8,252
In a setting where characters are steadily and methodically killed off, like we saw in the Alien RR, it's required to be a one-night deal. If you make it two or three days people will just leave, re-appear, and it'll be a nightmare to manage who is dead and who is not. In Alien people joined for the night, died horribly after having their fun, and left.
From a simple feasibility standpoint that's your biggest hurdle, and your second biggest is making it a clusterfuck with too many people. The more you add the slower it gets, and everyone is going to want a well-written death.
I don't know what this business is about not being able to handle x and y in a setting because of the TnB demographic. It's a pretty dumb set of standards because they're always so poorly defined and justified. There's a few things people here can't be trusted with, they're very obvious, but this is a fictional event, not a real one, so it's subject to the same standards and scrutiny we give HL2RP (a setting about a full on genocide not just a little murder), and there's not much reason we should hold this to some higher standard, the setting doesn't even demand you particularly push exploring the themes beyond the actual Battle Royale.
This isn't touchy like trying to RP a legitimate real-world genocide like was proposed in the Warsaw thread, it's no more touchy than the fictional genocide of the human species we all play daily on the HL2 server, a convenient fact most people who argue against it tend to forget, and honestly I'm just pressing this because it annoys me a little personally more than anything.
What about the children we're being proposed to RP. That's a restriction we just bend. They're 16, 18, 20,21, whatever is deemed to be adulthood. Probably 21 because I think that's how it is in the US and the minimum age on the main servers. Just make them university students, not high schoolers. That part isn't even a problem worth debating.
That said I don't have much faith in this actually happening, at least not for a long long time. After PUBG isn't so exciting anymore and has died down for sure. We have so many other, more interesting, ideas to work through instead.
From a simple feasibility standpoint that's your biggest hurdle, and your second biggest is making it a clusterfuck with too many people. The more you add the slower it gets, and everyone is going to want a well-written death.
I don't know what this business is about not being able to handle x and y in a setting because of the TnB demographic. It's a pretty dumb set of standards because they're always so poorly defined and justified. There's a few things people here can't be trusted with, they're very obvious, but this is a fictional event, not a real one, so it's subject to the same standards and scrutiny we give HL2RP (a setting about a full on genocide not just a little murder), and there's not much reason we should hold this to some higher standard, the setting doesn't even demand you particularly push exploring the themes beyond the actual Battle Royale.
This isn't touchy like trying to RP a legitimate real-world genocide like was proposed in the Warsaw thread, it's no more touchy than the fictional genocide of the human species we all play daily on the HL2 server, a convenient fact most people who argue against it tend to forget, and honestly I'm just pressing this because it annoys me a little personally more than anything.
What about the children we're being proposed to RP. That's a restriction we just bend. They're 16, 18, 20,21, whatever is deemed to be adulthood. Probably 21 because I think that's how it is in the US and the minimum age on the main servers. Just make them university students, not high schoolers. That part isn't even a problem worth debating.
That said I don't have much faith in this actually happening, at least not for a long long time. After PUBG isn't so exciting anymore and has died down for sure. We have so many other, more interesting, ideas to work through instead.