What I see here is two mistakes. One was the S2K in a mugging, sure, but the other one was the LOOC issue.
The point of mugging is, if done right, not to give the other person a chance to raise their weapon. You know in metal gear solid, if you get up behind an enemy, and aim your gun? Your character goes "FREEZE" and the guy raises his arms because
he's not an idiot. The same thing applies here. Now, I'm not saying you're an idiot, I assure you. I'm only referencing the scene in MGS.
What I'm getting at here is that you seem to have been the victim to surprise gunpoint, which you then complained about. Unfortunately, as
everybody in SRP is a protagonist in their eyes, you might feel as if it's some fault you didn't get a chance to react, as if it was a game mechanic. If that's how you feel, then please understand it's a world of players. It just won't be fair sometimes, either for you or against you.
If that's not what you thought, and instead, you just feel you should have gotten a chance to respond, then realize that not everybody gets that luxury. There have been many other players who get into combat and are the first to get sniped in the head in S2RP. No combat on their side, nothing. Just unlucky, like you are right now.
19:56:40 Night(STEAM_0:1:11796878) [LOCAL-OOC]: I don't even icly know about him.
19:56:47 Night(STEAM_0:1:11796878) [LOCAL-OOC]: So why Would I respond?
You don't have to know the mugger to respond to them. Do you have to know a mutant character personally to encounter them? Not at all.
In short, not only do I think the mugging went properly (aside from the script kill, though they seemed tired of your prolonged complaining [not that that excuses it]), but asking for a ban when you seem to be the one at greater fault seems to be the issue. Further, omitting the negative on your side (the complaining in LOOC) just makes you look worse.
I vote for no ban, and I vote that Tony gets a slap on the wrist for censorship of critical information.